Quotes of the Day

Sunday, Dec. 07, 2003

Open quotePamela Lipson can be forgiven for sounding a bit like the announcer in that classic comedy sketch who praises a new miracle foam: Shimmer is a floor wax! And a dessert topping! Get Lipson going, and the 36-year-old co-founder and president of Imagen will gush about how her product can distinguish faces in a crowd, recommend makeup, diagnose diseases and spot imperfections on a circuit board. What Lipson's six-year-old company — a spin-off of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (M.I.T.)--really does is make software that can find subtle similarities and differences in images of, well, just about anything. Imagen, based in Cambridge, Mass., is part of a group of this year's World Economic Forum Technology Pioneers. Collectively they could be called the digital detectives: firms that are developing technologies that can monitor everything from TV dinners to terrorists by analyzing digital signals and data about them.

The applications for these sleuthing technologies range from deciphering buying trends in retail outlets to identifying dangerous chemicals. Want to know how many razor blades are selling in Prague or Pittsburgh? Slap a radio tag — a computer chip that allows a product to be tracked on its journey from manufacturer to consumer — on every pack of Gillette blades, and you will get your answer in a hurry. That's the specialty of Alien Technology, an eight-year-old company based in Morgan Hill, Calif. The same tags can help track weapons too, and the U.S. Department of Defense just commanded its 43,000 sup-pliers to start using tags like those made by Alien. Worried about gas leaks from the furnace? Give Nanomix a call. The firm, based in Emeryville, Calif., is working on a miniature sensor, sometimes called an electronic nose, that detects hazardous chemicals in the environment. If these three firms were real detectives, Alien and Nanomix would be out on the streets doing surveillance, while Imagen would remain in the lab sorting through visual images for clues. Each of these companies plays its own role in the binary gumshoe game.

The thing all three have in common is digitization. Just about anything can be represented in digital form these days — not just text, movies and music but poison gas, human faces, packs of razor blades — you name it. Once information is digitized, it can be tracked, monitored and analyzed. The potential is evident in Lipson's vision of how people will use Imagen's algorithm-laden software. "Any data that can be represented as an image is amenable to analysis by Imagen's technology," says Lipson. "It is one of the very few technologies that can transcend different domains, from natural scenes to human faces to trademarks."

So far, Imagen has not been chasing terrorists or advising Hollywood starlets on their makeovers but concentrating on the far less glamorous — but more commercially viable — task of spotting defects on electronics boards before they end up in faulty cell phones or computers. Imagen's software is programmed to recognize patterns in much the same way the human brain learns to distinguish classes of objects (say, faces) as well as specific objects in that class — like your best friend's face. That's done by teaching the software, through trial and error, the common patterns that all faces share plus the specific patterns that make your best friend's face unique and then by training it to recognize those patterns in different conditions like varying light.

What works for faces works for circuit boards too. Imagen licenses its software to Teradyne, a maker of automated test equipment based in North Reading, Mass. (The companies are close; indeed, Imagen has an office based at Teradyne's headquarters.) Teradyne delivers Imagen technology to manufacturing companies in Asia and the U.S. by integrating it into Teradyne test equipment that scans circuit boards for flaws. Simply stated, a Teradyne machine takes pictures of the circuit board and hands over the image to Imagen software, which scours the snapshot for imperfections. This business allows Imagen to make a profit, though for Lipson, there have been other rewards. She met her future husband and Imagen co-founder Pawan Singha during their graduate days at M.I.T. Today he serves on Imagen's scientific advisory board while working as an M.I.T. professor of neuroscience.

Although Lipson won't reveal financial details, she says Imagen is making a profit — an impressive result for a company started with just $30,000 in prize money that Lipson won in 1997 as a doctoral student at M.I.T.'S Artificial Intelligence Laboratory. Imagen has not raised any venture capital either; indeed, Lipson claims to have spurned offers because, she says, working as a lone wolf, Imagen is free to develop its technology at its own pace and in several markets simultaneously. The company's only funding other than the M.I.T. prize and fees from Teradyne has been $100,000 from Alex d'Arbeloff, who until earlier this year was chairman of M.I.T. Corp., which oversees M.I.T.

While Imagen zeroes in on one market, Alien and Nanomix have learned a few hard lessons about focusing. Although Alien once concentrated on flexible computer screens, it is now putting all its efforts behind radio-frequency-identification (RFID) tags. The key to both flexible screens and RFID tags is Alien's patented manufacturing process, which allows chips to be generously sprinkled onto thin plastic sheets that can be easily attached to almost any type of product. Once fastened to a pack of razor blades, for example, a RFID chip emits a radio signal that allows the manufacturer or retailer to track if and when the product has been sold. Alien is the market leader in these chips and expects to make between 50 million and 100 million tags next year.

In Emeryville, Nanomix is determined to find its way to market with its own version of digital detective technology. The question is: Which market? Nanomix makes sensors that can be trained in a bewildering array of applications such as leak detection, medical-and environmental-hazard monitoring and industrial-process control. No wonder that five years after Marvin Cohen and fellow University of California, Berkeley professor Alex Zettl co-founded the company, they still don't expect to have product until 2006.

Their first target will be to replace current chemical sensors used to detect pollutants with cheaper and more efficient Nanomix versions. The U.S. market for sensors like these is a modest $100 million, says Nanomix co-chairman and venture backer Alex Wong. But you have to start somewhere: a $100 million real market beats a billion-dollar imagination. That's not to say Cohen and Zettl aren't still dreaming. They have not abandoned hope that their nano material could one day form the foundation for flat-panel displays, hydrogen-storage systems and even the quantum computer, which performs complex calculations at blistering speeds by using the principles of quantum physics. For Wong, it all boils down to a truism: "The proof is in getting useful products out," he says. Usefulness is, indeed, the key. The next big thing doesn't have to be a universal cure-all. Just a better floor wax will do.Close quote

  • Mark Halper
| Source: They can pick you out in a crowd, track what you buy — and maybe save your life